HS&E MAP practice question: Working at height (2 of 4)
D. High risk activities A free question from our original HS&E MAP practice exam. Try it, then open the answer to see why each option is right or wrong.
A contractor plans to use harnesses and lanyards for roof work, although a guard-railed scaffold is reasonably practicable.
What does HSE say?
Choose one answer.
AA. Use the scaffold
BB. Harnesses are fine, as they are cheaper
CC. Either is fine, as the contractor can choose
DD. Use nets instead, as they are always the best option
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: A
A. Right: Right. HSE says the hierarchy must be followed. Selecting equipment from lower down is not acceptable when a higher option is reasonably practicable.
B. Wrong: Wrong. Cost alone doesn't justify going lower down the hierarchy.
C. Wrong: Wrong. The hierarchy must be followed.
D. Wrong: Wrong. Nets mitigate falls. Preventing falls comes first.
Explanation
Follow the work at height hierarchy. Collective protection, such as guard rails, comes before personal protection.